Our Saloon listed as a "Hot Spot for Live Music" by Visit Indy!


Are you looking for a fun night out? Look no further than the Saloon at Bay Horse Inn. Enjoy live music by local artists, tasty food by local food trucks and your favorite beverages. 

On January 8, 2018 Visit Indy shared 4 spots for live music, food and drinks in south Indy. The Saloon at Bay Horse Inn was listed among them! Read the article, by Ken Kosky, here.  Others listed included The Willard, Mallow Run & Mashcraft Brewing.

Upcoming live music in the Saloon include:

Phil  Pierle on January 25, 2018

Phil  Pierle on January 25, 2018

Trace Thompson on February 9, 2018

Trace Thompson on February 9, 2018

Events are added often, so please check our online Events Calendar often.




"As you wish!" was our response.

When Mutual Savings Bank called us to see if we would be interested in helping them, of course our response was "As you wish".  They had sponsored the movie The Princess Bride at The Historic Artcraft Theatre here in Johnson County and hoped we could add a few touches.   Taking cues from The Princess Bride movie we looked to bring nature into the display.  Our team didn't have to go far as the property is filled with lots of branches this time of year.  Browse through the photos below to see the project come to life.  (Mac even donated a stick or two of his own and offered to supervised.)  Go see The Princess Bride this weekend! Support this terrific local theatre, The Historic Artcraft Theatre and our favorite local bank Mutual Savings Bank.  If you are getting married in the barn and want a custom twig display we can do that too! Contact Nicole to get started at (317) 760-8778.


Grand Opening Celebration Photographs

The Barn opened with a private grand opening celebration including friends, family, businesses and many community members who supported the development of Bay Horse Inn.

Photographs by Amanda DeBusk Photography

Ready, Set and Here We Go! Bay Horse Inn is OPEN!

Bay Horse Inn opened on Thursday, September 15, 2016. With a Ribbon cutting at noon, a Private Grand Opening celebration that evening followed by a fundraiser and 2 weddings the barn kicked off our first weekend full force! 

Below are a few photographs from our Grand Opening Celebration (More coming soon!) Thanks to the Flying Cupcake, in Greenwood, for sharing these. 

If you'd like to see the barn please contact Nicole at (317) 760-8778 or nicole@barnatbayhorse.com.  You can also check out our Community Events calendar for upcoming events that may interest you. 


A sign of good things to come!

Bay Horse Inn has been bestowed good luck as we've had several days filled with rainbows! Even with all of the rain this spring season we are on schedule! Duke Construction has been very busy and the barn will open as scheduled in September! 

Barn at Bay Horse Inn Raising Funds for LJC.


The Bay Horse Inn was proud to donate an event to the Leadership Johnson County Wine Tasting Tour of France.  The live auctioned package included a party for 60 in the Saloon including food, by Johnny Carino's, and Music by Black Water Gypsy.

Bidding started at $750 and the winning bid of $1300 was won, by Robert Heuchan's, of Mutual Savings Bank. All funds raised, by this event, benefit Leadership Johnson County at Franklin College.  The program started 22 years ago and is a huge influence in developing leaders within Johnson County.  People from different townships, backgrounds and occupations come together each year, to discuss and strengthen, our community. Learn more about Leadership Johnson County. 

Amanda Cottingham, Bay Horse Inn owner, also sponsored a table.  Joining Bay Horse Inn staff were Rob Henderson, from Mutual Savings Bank, and his wife Brandi. Our City Council Representative Jimmy Ison and his wife Mindy also joined our table.  

We look forward to participating in this spectacular event again!